Yep. I know it's not the done thing

hlb

RIP
Joined
16 May 2001
Messages
26,774
Location
Any Pub Lancashire or Wales
Visit site
Yep. I know it\'s not the done thing

But though this needed posting here as well.


Theres been alot of complaint about brixham not advising the weather forcast on 16. Most times Brixham wont acknowlege that there is a problem and pretend they have had no complaints.

So whilst storm bound in Brixham, I thought I'd get to the bottom of it.

First visit, I got told a load of tecnical reasons why some folk could not hear the broadcast. Blah, Blah, Blah.

Then by chance, I visited the harbour office to pay the dues. Conversation got around to weather forcasts and HM said. They had not got the Brixham forcast for months! Even had to reprogram his radio to pick up chanel 23 on my advice.

I thought, this is bloody rediculas, even the HM dont know. God knows how any visiting boat suppsed to know the time and chanel of the forcast. It's not in the almanac, well not actualy the right time anyway.

So back to the coast guards.
Part of the problem it seems, is the weather forcast is designed for boats at sea. But they have now discovered that most folk these days like to get a forcast, before they set off.

Finally one of the CG fessed up. Powers way above them, had told them to turn off all the ariels except prawle point. (Prawle Point cant actually be heard, unless your passing err Prawle Point) For the few second duation of broadcasting when to go to chanel 23 or whatever, for safety reasons, being that there maybe a mayday call in those few seconds.

Course, I pointed out. Well every one that knows, is going to have switched over to 23 half an hour ago, by that method. So his mayday is going to fall on deaf ears.

The coast guard men shrugged helplessly, but are logging complains to send to there boss.

How ever they did point out, that they were happy to give the weather forcast out to anyone who missed it! Seemingly defeating the object of keeping broadcasting down to the minimum.

Oh yes. They agreed that this should be posted in the boating press, to get it sorted out. So who's listening!!
 

Bodach na mara

Well-known member
Joined
21 Aug 2002
Messages
2,603
Location
Western Scotland
Visit site
Re: Yep. I know it\'s not the done thing

Clyde CG are broadcasting the forecast on all ariels but the last few days I have been on the boat the timing has been all over the place. On one occasion, the midday broadcast was about 1210 and the next time it was at 1430. As far as I can tell it should be at 1320!

I know that "casualty working" can cause delay or cancellation, but the forecast is a fairly important part of passage planning and safety.
 

DJE

Well-known member
Joined
21 Jun 2004
Messages
7,655
Location
Fareham
www.casl.uk.com
Re: Yep. I know it\'s not the done thing

I've been noticing for some time that Solent CG are clear as a bell at all times except when they are announcing the MSI broadcasts so maybe they're doing something similar. But Southampton VTS announce their traffic braodcasts on Ch16 at what seems like one hour intervals. So they're not worried about clogging up Ch16.

When I noticed the new broadcast times aren't in the Almanac I went to the website and downloaded the table from there. But it doesn't say whether the times are BST or UTC (which is a bit sloppy for MCA). I sent MCA an email asking for clarification. (They appear to be BST at the moment so I was wondering what will happen when the clocks go back in October.) Their reply made no mention of BST or UTC but said "Broadcast times will be the same throughout the year." I think I'll just wait and see what happens in October.
 

Bodach na mara

Well-known member
Joined
21 Aug 2002
Messages
2,603
Location
Western Scotland
Visit site
Re: Yep. I know it\'s not the done thing

Thanks Peter and Silkie. I wonder how I missed that! I was still at "work" in February so I should have noticed the change in my usual prowl of the internet.

I suppose that the UTC/BST ambiguity will be sorted the first time I get to the boat for a full day. As in other posts, the weather has been less than perfect on the Clyde. It has started pouring again just now, just when I stretched out the cockpit tent in the garden to repair it.
 
Top