Which Ensign?

cruisingsam

Member
Joined
27 Jul 2004
Messages
232
Location
Dublin
Visit site
Which ensign can I fly?

Rascal is based in Ireland and owned by an Englishman and an Irishman (no jokes please!!)

We are both resident in Ireland.

She will be registered under the ISA Certificate of Identity scheme.

We do want to go through the full registration process for either Ireland or the UK.

As I understand it we cannot fly the Irish ensign as you have to be wholly Irish owned or be on the full register.

We cannot fly the Red ensign as we are not UK registered, as we cannot register under the SSR as neither of us are resident in the UK.

So which, if any, ensign can we fly?
 

cruisingsam

Member
Joined
27 Jul 2004
Messages
232
Location
Dublin
Visit site
Hi Mike,
I have a UK passport but the guy I own Rascal with has an Irish passport. We have a ROI ships radio license and callsign/mmsi. My reading is we fall between the cracks on ensigns as we are dual nationalitily owners??
 

arto

Member
Joined
26 Nov 2004
Messages
171
Location
London
Visit site
Surely it's down to where the boat is registered and has nothing to do with the nationality of the owner.

(Presumably this is why it's possible for there to be so many big ships registered in Panama and Liberia when presumably their owners are nationals of other countries).
 
Joined
27 May 2002
Messages
11,172
Visit site
Re: Another ensign quandry.

My Yacht is registered in Caen, France.
The VHF is registered in France.
Berthed in Portsmouth.
I live and work in the UK and hold a UK passport.
Politically I would be happy to use a Euro ensign if legal.
 

pragmatist

Well-known member
Joined
7 May 2003
Messages
1,426
Visit site
Re: Another ensign quandry.

Theoretically under UK legislation I believe it ain't - but I've been wanting to do it for ages - fancy a nice big Euro ensign with UJ defacement - suspect it would cause more of a riot than some of the things I say on this forum tho' - one day when I've had the odd glass or two of something I'll make one up, fly it and see what flak flies back /forums/images/graemlins/shocked.gif

Personally I think its a nonsense that the French can fly a defaced EU ensign and its not "accepted" here. Ducks beneath parapet smartly ...
 

MASH

N/A
Joined
8 Mar 2004
Messages
2,188
Visit site
Re: Another ensign quandry.

Nice big euro flag is a nice idea (just don't go calling it an ensign) as long as it is in little squares and on a hook in the heads.

Prag, it matters not what we think of these things, that is just how they are. In France you can pee in the street. Here?
Different ships, different cap tallies. And I'm proud of mine.
 

arto

Member
Joined
26 Nov 2004
Messages
171
Location
London
Visit site
Re: Another ensign quandry.

Peeing in the street? Pretty much normal behaviour during the evenings in London these days.
 

Sybarite

Well-known member
Joined
7 Dec 2002
Messages
27,681
Location
France
Visit site
Re: Another ensign quandry.

" In France you can pee in the street " - and you can get prosecuted for it as in the UK....

John
 

Sybarite

Well-known member
Joined
7 Dec 2002
Messages
27,681
Location
France
Visit site
Not as simple as that I think. I live in France and my boat is registered there. Because I have a British passport I was not allowed to wear the French flag and was obliged to wear the red ensign. The "Acte de Francisation" is reserved for French nationals.

Some customs men believe that the rules have changed but they are unsure of themselves. When I asked for confirmation at the Douanes stand at the last Salon Nautique in Paris they confirmed to me that it was correct for me to continue to wear the red ensign.

The customs men who challenged me said that I should have an SSR cert. I told them that one had to be a resident Brit to get this. The only alternative would have been to get full registration. As this would involve physically bringing the boat to the UK for measurement etc I told them that I would categorically refuse to do this: danger of the crossing (..!!) additional cost for me compared to a French national (discriminatory) Each time they told me that they would seek clarification and come back to me. They never did.

John
 

bobfrost

New member
Joined
13 Nov 2004
Messages
1,740
Location
18A, Linear North
Visit site
http://www.wycombe.gov.uk/news/news.asp?step=2&pid=601

Slightly off subject but this link relates to the first prosecution in High Wycombe for urinating in public in a 'designated area' (2002)

If it is illegal to pee in the street why did they have to use a new by-law? Is one allowed to pee outside the designated area?

Apocraphacally (sp) I was always told that it was legal to pee against the offside wheels of a brewery dray wagon.
 

Shakey

New member
Joined
5 Apr 2004
Messages
464
Location
The People\'s Republic Of South Yorkshire
Visit site
IMHO, the ensign refers to the boat not to the owners.

If Irish law doesn't allow you to register the boat as Irish due to their nationality requirements, then you can probably register the boat as British and wear a red ensign. I don't think you need to register under the SSR to show the red ensign.

I could of course be wrong.....

You could register the boat as Panamanian or Liberian if you're really stuck. ;-)
 

pragmatist

Well-known member
Joined
7 May 2003
Messages
1,426
Visit site
[ QUOTE ]
You could register the boat as Panamanian or Liberian if you're really stuck. ;-)

[/ QUOTE ]

Probably cheaper too - certainly than renewing full registration /forums/images/graemlins/shocked.gif
 

cruisingsam

Member
Joined
27 Jul 2004
Messages
232
Location
Dublin
Visit site
Thanks for all this!!
The problem is that we can register in Ireland, the UK, Panama, Liberia etc etc on the full register if we wanted but the cost is extortionate, she is "only" a 24ft yacht. That is why we are going with the ISA Certificate of Registration.
The Irish rules say any yacht with full registration can fly the Tricolour but only yachts with wholly Irish ownership can fly the flag if not on the full register.
Reading the MCA website seems to be the same for the UK.
I think we'll go with the view that when I'm out then it's the red ensign and when it's my co-owner it's the Tricolour!
 
G

Guest

Guest
Where a boat is not registered in Britain, if she is under 24m in length she can fly the appropriate British ensign provided (i) she is not registered in any other country; AND (ii) all the owners are "qualified owners".

To quote the definition of "qualified owners":
""qualified owners" means persons of such description qualified to own British ships as is prescribed by regulations made by the Secretary of State"

I can't find a copy of the Sec of State's regulations - clearly the English owner will be a "qualified owner", the question is whether the Irish one is too - the law clearly states that ALL owners must be. I suspect that Irish citizens can be "qualified owners", but you should check this.

The relevant bit of legislation is S. 1(2) of the Merchant Shipping Act 1995.
 
Top