G
Guest
Guest
[ QUOTE ]
Personally I think the thread should not have been pulled. There was a lot of useful information coming out from people 'the other side of the desk' which was of considerable collective value to anyone in the job market, and I think we have lost a useful reference source.
Nor do I think that if a poster puts up something contentious, and finds forum opinion against him, that the thread should be pulled just because it is embarassing to have so many people disagree!
I think there is a clear distinction between the type of poster who simply attacks and tries to rubbish a posting and the poster, and the kind of considered and factual responses we were getting from many people 'in the know' in this posting.
A few replies were not very helpful it's true, but I see no reason to pull a thread which gave a lot of factual and interesting information, just to save someone a red face!
Its not as if we can even see him blushing!
[/ QUOTE ]
As one who "posted from other side of the desk" .... being a Company owner and director ... I posted in honest views and observations ref. CV's etc. and my interpretation of the thread and initial post. But I still feel the thread was rightly pulled ...
As I already said - it was up for long enough for most here to have read and diegested what was written ...
Personally I think the thread should not have been pulled. There was a lot of useful information coming out from people 'the other side of the desk' which was of considerable collective value to anyone in the job market, and I think we have lost a useful reference source.
Nor do I think that if a poster puts up something contentious, and finds forum opinion against him, that the thread should be pulled just because it is embarassing to have so many people disagree!
I think there is a clear distinction between the type of poster who simply attacks and tries to rubbish a posting and the poster, and the kind of considered and factual responses we were getting from many people 'in the know' in this posting.
A few replies were not very helpful it's true, but I see no reason to pull a thread which gave a lot of factual and interesting information, just to save someone a red face!
Its not as if we can even see him blushing!
[/ QUOTE ]
As one who "posted from other side of the desk" .... being a Company owner and director ... I posted in honest views and observations ref. CV's etc. and my interpretation of the thread and initial post. But I still feel the thread was rightly pulled ...
As I already said - it was up for long enough for most here to have read and diegested what was written ...
