Radar detectors?

scarlett

New member
Joined
21 Dec 2002
Messages
1,118
Location
French Canals 2007 on, Hull most of winter. previo
Visit site
Has anybody used one of those detectors designed for speeding radars in their boat? And was it any use?

What I have in mind is that one of the 'bands' covered may be the same as one of the ships' radars and as it is proposed to ban the sale of the speed camera detectors, action is necessary soon. There are many for sale for less than £100 and may be better than nothing in dense fog if they give a warning.

Ta
 

Thistle

Well-known member
Joined
2 Oct 2004
Messages
3,973
Location
Here
Visit site
I don't know if the frequencies used are the same as marine radars (though I doubt if they are) but I don't think this sounds like a good idea at all. At best the device could only tell you that a radar emitter was somewhere within range. It wouldn't give you any idea of range, bearing, or of direction or speed of travel of the other vessel. Nor would it give you any information about vessels not using radar or about land.

I'll give it a miss, thanks.
 

jackho

Member
Joined
22 Mar 2003
Messages
502
Visit site
For £129 you can buy an A.I.S. engine (NASA) which can display ship movements as an overlay on your charts provided of course you use a laptop or similar as a chart plotter. Just a thought!!!
 

Gazza

Member
Joined
30 Jul 2001
Messages
218
Location
Cornwood near Plymouth, Devon
Visit site
I've just completed a Transatlantic circuit and had a Watchman Radar Detector fitted (cheaper than a CARD, but doesn't give direction of signal). It worked well, but I did find, over 9000 miles, a significant number of ships, including a massive bulk carrier, that did not have their radar on. This seemed to happen day or night, and when I spoke to one ship on VHF he gave the impression that it was normal procedure.

I've been told that shipping companies lease radar rather than buy it, so costs are kept down with less use.

I would certainly think about upgrading my radar to a more modern design that allowed periodic and automatic sweeps if I did it again.

Radar detectors (marine ones anyway) work well, but only when the other vessel has its radar on!!

Gary Miller
 
Top