Jabsco inlet anti-syphon - why?

R

Ric

Well-Known Member
Joined
8 Dec 2003
Messages
1,723
Visit site
My boat has a half-hearted attempt at an anti-syphon loop in the water inlet to the Jabsco toilet, installed by the manufacturer (Jeanneau). I say half-hearted because the top of the loop is 30cm or so above waterline when the boat is at rest, but very close to the waterline when healed, if not below. I can't see any advantage at all to an anti-syphon loop in the water inlet since the pipe will always be full anyway. Wouldn't it be better to suppress the loop and keep the pipe as short as possible?
 
If the top of your toilet bowl is below sea level then syphon could start unless you close the sea cock. A shorter pipe would probably increase the likelyhood of it happening.

I guess any anti-syphon loop, and 30 cm above the waterline actually seems pretty good, is better than none. :)

Richard
 
Ric said:
I can't see any advantage at all to an anti-syphon loop in the water inlet since the pipe will always be full anyway.
Click to expand...

The point of an anti-siphon valve is to ensure that a loop isn't full, by letting in air. If it were full, water could siphon over the top, hence the name.

There's no such thing as an anti-siphon loop. A loop above the waterline exists so that you don't just have a hose straight from the sea into the inside of your boat. For things like exhausts and bilge-pump outlets above the waterline, the loop won't be full of water when not in use so there is no need for a valve. Otherwise, the loop is potentially susceptible to siphoning and the valve is needed.

Putting an anti-siphon valve before a suction pump (whether engine or toilet) is pointless, because the pump will just suck in air through the valve instead of sucking in water.

A toilet below the waterline should have a loop between the pump and the bowl, with an anti-siphon valve in the top of it. No loop or valve is needed or wanted in the hose from seacock to pump.

Pete
 
RichardS said:
If the top of your toilet bowl is below sea level then syphon could start unless you close the sea cock. A shorter pipe would probably increase the likelyhood of it happening.

(...)
Richard
Click to expand...
That's what used to happen on my boat; it was a bit of a nuisance. Since fitting the anti-siphon gadget (between pump and bowl, as 'prv' says) it never happens.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Ric said:
My boat has a half-hearted attempt at an anti-syphon loop in the water inlet to the Jabsco toilet, installed by the manufacturer (Jeanneau). I say half-hearted because the top of the loop is 30cm or so above waterline when the boat is at rest, but very close to the waterline when healed, if not below. I can't see any advantage at all to an anti-syphon loop in the water inlet since the pipe will always be full anyway. Wouldn't it be better to suppress the loop and keep the pipe as short as possible?
Click to expand...

If the top of the toilet is below the waterline ( static or heeled) there should be a vented loop, replacing the short hose normally supplied between the pump and the inlet to the bowl, rising to a point at least 20cm above the water line , even when heeled.

The vent valve at the top of the loop will admit air and break the syphon which will otherwise tend to try to fill and overflow the toilet bowl until you shut the seacock.

There should be similar vented loop in the discharge hose , although the combined efforts of the joker valve and the Twist and lock facility should prevent a back syphon via the discharge .... but not reliably.
 
Last edited:
prv said:
The point of an anti-siphon valve is to ensure that a loop isn't full, by letting in air. If it were full, water could siphon over the top, hence the name.

There's no such thing as an anti-siphon loop. A loop above the waterline exists so that you don't just have a hose straight from the sea into the inside of your boat. For things like exhausts and bilge-pump outlets above the waterline, the loop won't be full of water when not in use so there is no need for a valve. Otherwise, the loop is potentially susceptible to siphoning and the valve is needed.

Putting an anti-siphon valve before a suction pump (whether engine or toilet) is pointless, because the pump will just suck in air through the valve instead of sucking in water.

A toilet below the waterline should have a loop between the pump and the bowl, with an anti-siphon valve in the top of it. No loop or valve is needed or wanted in the hose from seacock to pump.

Pete
Click to expand...

I'm assuming that when the OP says the "water inlet to the bowl", he means the water pipe from the pump to the bowl since, as you say, if the loop was in the pipe from the seacock the toilet presumably wouldn't flush?

(Using the term "loop" to mean the inverted turn/valve assembly)

Richard
 
RichardS said:
I'm assuming that when the OP says the "water inlet to the bowl", he means the water pipe from the pump to the bowl
Click to expand...

But he doesn't say that, he says "water inlet to the toilet". Which I take to mean the hose from seacock to pump inlet, because half-arsed installers invariably fail to understand that they might need to remove the supplied length of pipe from pump to bowl.

RichardS said:
since, as you say, if the loop was in the pipe from the seacock the toilet presumably wouldn't flush?
Click to expand...

With just a loop there, it will flush fine. With a valve in the loop it wouldn't, at least not well, but I suspect there is no anti-siphon valve anywhere in the system because the installer seemingly didn't understand what he was doing.

Pete
 
VicS said:
Only when the toilet is above the heeled waterline. (Option 2 + figure2) If its below the water line option 1 + figure 1 appliy
Click to expand...

Both pictures show a direct run from seacock to pump inlet, as the OP says (and as is correct).

What his boat seems to be missing is the loop and anti-siphon valve between pump and bowl.

Pete
 
prv said:
Both pictures show a direct run from seacock to pump inlet, as the OP says (and as is correct).

Pete
Click to expand...

Yes you have to have a connection between the seacock and the pump .......... or you get no flushing water .... unless of course you use fresh water
 
prv said:
But he doesn't say that, he says "water inlet to the toilet".
Pete
Click to expand...

Apologies Pete. You're right. I just read "toilet" as "toilet bowl" but it could just as well mean "toilet pump".

My toilet loops, which I have now removed as my toilets are above sea-level and I don't heel, both included anti-syphon valves ...... but is there ever a use on a boat for loops which don't include a valve?

Richard
 
RichardS said:
(...)

My toilet loops, which I have now removed as my toilets are above sea-level and I don't heel, both included anti-syphon valves ...... but is there ever a use on a boat for loops which don't include a valve?

Richard
Click to expand...
Yes. My lavatory is below the water line. Although, as I said above, my inlet pipe needs an anti-siphon valve the large diameter discharge pipe does not have one. It is looped up above the water line. If it wasn't, water would flow straight into the pan. Why it doesn't act as a siphon, like the inlet pipe did, is a mystery to me.
 
RichardS said:
is there ever a use on a boat for loops which don't include a valve?
Click to expand...

You only get a siphon when there's a continuous column of water all the way from the sea, up and over the loop, to a point below the sea's surface.

So definitely no need on an engine exhaust, as the water will always be mixed up with gas rather than being a continuous column.

I also wouldn't consider a valve essential on overboard discharges that exit above the waterline, like bilge pumps. Even though when heeled over the exit might be below the average waterline, so that if the pipe is full after running the pump a siphon is theoretically possible, in practice the motion of the boat and waves in such conditions means that the skin fitting will take in a big gulp of air within a second or two and that will break the siphon.

A decent loop is still needed, especially with centrifugal pumps, as they have no other protection against backflow.

Pete
 
parsifal said:
Yes. My lavatory is below the water line. Although, as I said above, my inlet pipe needs an anti-siphon valve the large diameter discharge pipe does not have one. It is looped up above the water line. If it wasn't, water would flow downhill into the pan. Why it doesn't act as a siphon, like the inlet pipe did, is a mystery to me.
Click to expand...

Mostly because of the joker valve in the toilet, I imagine. But the makers say not to rely on that.

Pete
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Share this page

Top