Hurricane season

geem

Well-known member
Joined
27 Apr 2006
Messages
8,043
Location
Caribbean
Visit site
Lots of people leave boats in Le Marin, Martinique in a marina for hurricane season. The wise ones take off the sails, sprayhood and bimini. Clearly, this guy has no idea of the consequences of leaving all that stuff up to flog in the wind when it's blowing like stink.
In a marina environment, it only takes one boat to come loose during a hurricane to create complete carnage for other boats nearby. Leaving sails up during hurricane season on unattended boats should be banned in those marinas in my view.
A loose genoa will lean a boat over drastically in 75mph winds such that mast and rigging clash with adjacent boats, masts come down. You can imagine the carnage.
We were in Le Marin a couple of weeks ago. A direct hit of a full strength hurricane there would be utter carnage. There are thousands of boats in the marina and on a tightly packed mooring field plus many yachts at anchor. Circa 2000 boats in total
 

SaltyC

Well-known member
Joined
15 Feb 2020
Messages
491
Location
Yorkshire
Visit site
Lots of people leave boats in Le Marin, Martinique in a marina for hurricane season. The wise ones take off the sails, sprayhood and bimini. Clearly, this guy has no idea of the consequences of leaving all that stuff up to flog in the wind when it's blowing like stink.
In a marina environment, it only takes one boat to come loose during a hurricane to create complete carnage for other boats nearby. Leaving sails up during hurricane season on unattended boats should be banned in those marinas in my view.
A loose genoa will lean a boat over drastically in 75mph winds such that mast and rigging clash with adjacent boats, masts come down. You can imagine the carnage.
We were in Le Marin a couple of weeks ago. A direct hit of a full strength hurricane there would be utter carnage. There are thousands of boats in the marina and on a tightly packed mooring field plus many yachts at anchor. Circa 2000 boats in total
I cannot believe someone will not remove a genoa in hurrican alley. I am surprised at the numbers who leave genoas furled in Britain when they have no intention ofgoing sailing. 10 mins effort, arriving and leaving.
 

johnalison

Well-known member
Joined
14 Feb 2007
Messages
40,966
Location
Essex
Visit site
I cannot believe someone will not remove a genoa in hurrican alley. I am surprised at the numbers who leave genoas furled in Britain when they have no intention ofgoing sailing. 10 mins effort, arriving and leaving.
We get few hurricanes in Essex. It is more than enough effort to hoist my jib once a year without wanting to do this every time I feel like going out for a sail. I double secure my furling line and coil the spinnaker halyard many times round the sail when leaving the boat, and feel well able to withstand the worst that the Met Office can throw at me.
 

Kelpie

Well-known member
Joined
15 May 2005
Messages
7,767
Location
Afloat
Visit site
I cannot believe someone will not remove a genoa in hurrican alley. I am surprised at the numbers who leave genoas furled in Britain when they have no intention ofgoing sailing. 10 mins effort, arriving and leaving.
Can you please come and do my genoa, I reckon it's closer to an hour by the time it's all done, and that's assuming I've got a spacious alongside berth to give space to flake it, and a competent helper. And that I don't mind giving up the cabin space to store it.
 

Bajansailor

Well-known member
Joined
27 Dec 2004
Messages
6,495
Location
Marine Surveyor in Barbados
Visit site
Michael Briant's Forum name is @Sea Devil (https://forums.ybw.com/members/sea-devil.9021/ ), but YBW says that they have not seen him since February.

Kelpie makes a good point above - however if anybody is leaving their boat for the summer in a location where there is a reasonable chance of a hurricane happening, either ashore or afloat in a marina, then it would be prudent to spend that extra hour to take the genoa off and stow it down below.
 

Stemar

Well-known member
Joined
12 Sep 2001
Messages
23,888
Location
Home - Southampton, Boat - Gosport
Visit site
ISTM that yes, it's a pain to have to set up the genny, bimini and dodgers every time - I wouldn't bother either when leaving the boat for a few days - I could always come and take 'em off, or pay someone to do it if I couldn't get there, when seriously bad weather threatens, but leaving the boat for several weeks at a time when hurricanes are likely, you bet I'd make the effort.
 

SaltyC

Well-known member
Joined
15 Feb 2020
Messages
491
Location
Yorkshire
Visit site
Can you please come and do my genoa, I reckon it's closer to an hour by the time it's all done, and that's assuming I've got a spacious alongside berth to give space to flake it, and a competent helper. And that I don't mind giving up the cabin space to store it.
On the 31 footer, took circa 15 mins, Flaked on deck singlehanded. ...........The 37 footer is a slightly longer process using marina walkway. Both bagged and stored under forecabin bunks.
 

Kelpie

Well-known member
Joined
15 May 2005
Messages
7,767
Location
Afloat
Visit site
On the 31 footer, took circa 15 mins, Flaked on deck singlehanded. ...........The 37 footer is a slightly longer process using marina walkway. Both bagged and stored under forecabin bunks.
And on a 1970s headsail driven 39ft boat, with a huge overlapping genoa, and a babystay cutting in to the deck space, it's a different story.
I do remove all canvas if I'm leaving the boat for the winter, but that's the only time.
If I was caught out with a hurricane approaching, I'd think about it, but would rather put my energies in to being somewhere else.
 

johnalison

Well-known member
Joined
14 Feb 2007
Messages
40,966
Location
Essex
Visit site
My jib is only 110% but laminate, and it is about as much as I can do just to lift it in its bag. The pontoon, if I could get it there is a metal grid (Titchmarsh for those who know it), and not suitable for folding sails. I have no area of deck to fold the sail on, especially as the lowers come onto the deck, so the best I can do is to make some sort of sausage of sail and bundle it into its bag for sorting out at home. It is not a lot better even with two people. Hoisting the jib can vary from moderately tedious to very tedious if the wind is unhelpful, and almost requires two people since the halyard is in the cockpit and the sail won’t easily feed itself in the track. I have sailed smaller boats and those with soft Dacron sails where these tasks were easy, especially with hanked-on sails, but to forego one of the great advantages of a furling jib would be quite daft, which is why no-one does.
 

geem

Well-known member
Joined
27 Apr 2006
Messages
8,043
Location
Caribbean
Visit site
My jib is only 110% but laminate, and it is about as much as I can do just to lift it in its bag. The pontoon, if I could get it there is a metal grid (Titchmarsh for those who know it), and not suitable for folding sails. I have no area of deck to fold the sail on, especially as the lowers come onto the deck, so the best I can do is to make some sort of sausage of sail and bundle it into its bag for sorting out at home. It is not a lot better even with two people. Hoisting the jib can vary from moderately tedious to very tedious if the wind is unhelpful, and almost requires two people since the halyard is in the cockpit and the sail won’t easily feed itself in the track. I have sailed smaller boats and those with soft Dacron sails where these tasks were easy, especially with hanked-on sails, but to forego one of the great advantages of a furling jib would be quite daft, which is why no-one does.
My 700sqft genoa with 10oz cloth is a two man lift once in the bag. The cloth is stiff as it Vectran. Regardless of the difficulty of removing and reinstating the sail on the furler, It would always be removed if we were leaving the boat unattended in hurricane season.
I will be replacing the forestay wire this week so the sail will be coming off. I little reminder of how hard it is to do😬
 

BurnitBlue

Well-known member
Joined
22 Oct 2005
Messages
4,537
Location
In Transit
Visit site
Whén I cruised the Bahamas in my first prout with her large genoa, i used an open sock fastened with plastic hooks. Lots of them so I hoisted the sock a few feet, fasten a hook hoist another few feet etc. When fully hoisted it looked really neat and protective.

Until one storm when I was woken by an awfull racket. The sock being loose and flappy was in an absolute rage and shaking the whole boat. Next day the storm subsided allowing me to lower the thing still flapping. No damage, however the sock was replaced by an anti UV strip later which the sock was designed to emulate.
 

Zing

Well-known member
Joined
7 Feb 2014
Messages
8,075
Visit site
I have kept my boat in the hurricane zone for many years. I always remove its sails even though it’s a faff, a half day job for two. I now do also the in-mast furling mainsail. They have been known to unfurl themselves and cause chaos in a hurricane. I’m always on the hard too. Leaving it in a marina is just asking for trouble. So sorry, Sailing Gently, I think you are taking a big risk with your boat.
 

BurnitBlue

Well-known member
Joined
22 Oct 2005
Messages
4,537
Location
In Transit
Visit site
I have kept my boat in the hurricane zone for many years. I always remove its sails even though it’s a faff, a half day job for two. I now do also the in-mast furling mainsail. They have been known to unfurl themselves and cause chaos in a hurricane. I’m always on the hard too. Leaving it in a marina is just asking for trouble. So sorry, Sailing Gently, I think you are taking a big risk with your boat.
A major problem for me with 5 years in the hurricane zone was the stress of following a threat via radio. Many times it missed but still left me a jibbering wreck for a few days. That was pre-internet so I wonder if it is any better with instant up-todate tracking and so many "channels" to choose from?
 

Stemar

Well-known member
Joined
12 Sep 2001
Messages
23,888
Location
Home - Southampton, Boat - Gosport
Visit site
I reckon it's probably a bit of both. Better because of more accurate forecasting, but worse because of inaccurate "We're all gonna die" headlines from the usual sources - There are plenty of "red top tabloid" internet channels, as well as the more reliable ones.

I'm in the UK, so we don't have to worry about hurricanes (Michael Fish was right, it wasn't a hurricane, even if there were hurricane strength winds), but we do get weather to worry about a few times a year, and a storm where I'm going to prep the boat and bring her to the pontoon to sit it out every couple of years.
 

Zing

Well-known member
Joined
7 Feb 2014
Messages
8,075
Visit site
A major problem for me with 5 years in the hurricane zone was the stress of following a threat via radio. Many times it missed but still left me a jibbering wreck for a few days. That was pre-internet so I wonder if it is any better with instant up-todate tracking and so many "channels" to choose from?
I mostly look at the National Hurricane Centre. No hyperbole there. Also synoptic charts, such as with weatherfax. Again free of B.S.
 

capnsensible

Well-known member
Joined
15 Mar 2007
Messages
46,581
Location
Atlantic
Visit site
A major problem for me with 5 years in the hurricane zone was the stress of following a threat via radio. Many times it missed but still left me a jibbering wreck for a few days. That was pre-internet so I wonder if it is any better with instant up-todate tracking and so many "channels" to choose from?
Wunderground tropical used to be a great website for hurricane information but it seems to have lost. Its way in recent years, sadly.
 

geem

Well-known member
Joined
27 Apr 2006
Messages
8,043
Location
Caribbean
Visit site
I mostly look at the National Hurricane Centre. No hyperbole there. Also synoptic charts, such as with weatherfax. Again free of B.S.
The ECMWF is very good at tracking early hurricanes. We use the Windy proffessional app. With a Digicel roaming package we have excellent Internet from the BvIs all the way down to Trinidad. Its very easy to stay informed. There are good local Internet weather stations with no hype and sensationalising online. Spice Weather in Grenada being one useful source
 
Last edited:
Top