Fixed VHF replacement

Peter

Member
Joined
31 May 2001
Messages
345
Location
cumbria
Visit site
Got to buy a new fixed VHF, old u/s, could send for repair but need new quickly. It is the radio not aerial or anything obvious as all checks carried out and everything OK and check with a borrowed radio which worked. Any recommendation for make, model etc for approx £200 as cannot find any good reviews.


Peter
 

Alpha22

Active member
Joined
22 Sep 2003
Messages
1,413
Location
Cambridgeshire
Visit site
They are all much of a muchness at that price. Look for what matters to you.

I think the interface design is very important. I would want a knob for volume, squelch AND channel select. I don't like the idea of having to hit small rubber buttons to select anything I may need in a hurry. If I want to re-tune to the weather forecast.... I don't want to have to press a button a million times. Spinning a knob is far more intuitive.
The entry level Raymarine and the Lawrence Link-5 look like good contenders for me.

But.... each to their own.
 

Durcott

Member
Joined
10 Jul 2006
Messages
194
Location
East Cowes, Isle of Wight
Visit site
Hi - I bought Icom's entry level VHF last year and hated it. It was a damned good radio mind, but the interface just didn't work while bouncing up and down feeling grim.

I sold the boat, and was happy to keep the radio on it and revert to an ancient Navco affair. in my 'new' boat.

By the look of it, this year's ICOM has a much bigger screen, but just think twice about the interface. There's no point in having tri-watch, for example, if it takes a 6 month course to find it under a complex button-mash-fest.
 

oldgit

Well-known member
Joined
6 Nov 2001
Messages
28,244
Location
Medway
Visit site
If service and back up matter to you there is one outfit with a proven track record.
ICOM are still prepared to repair FOC their marine radios with a ceramic filter fault even though in some cases the radios are rather old.
It makes them(the radio) a bit deaf.
Try that with your non Icom radio and see what the importer comes back with.:)
 

prv

Well-known member
Joined
29 Nov 2009
Messages
37,361
Location
Southampton
Visit site
I've similarly heard less-than-good stuff about Icom's user-interface. Quality of construction and effectiveness of the radio they are good at, but software design - not so much. Didn't matter when radios were simple (channel, volume, squelch, that's about it) but it becomes a problem with the range of features nowadays - in particular DSC, which you will have to react to even if you never want to initiate.

My vote is for Standard Horizon, selected from their range according to budget. Although, if you think you will ever want AIS, it may be worth splashing out on the GX2100 as it works out much easier and almost certainly cheaper than a separate aerial, wiring, and receiver.

Pete
 

FishyInverness

New member
Joined
12 Oct 2010
Messages
1,299
Location
Inverness
www.gaelforcegroup.com
If service and back up matter to you there is one outfit with a proven track record.
ICOM are still prepared to repair FOC their marine radios with a ceramic filter fault even though in some cases the radios are rather old.
It makes them(the radio) a bit deaf.
Try that with your non Icom radio and see what the importer comes back with.:)

For reference : Standard Horizon after sales support is also second to none.
 

ditchcrawler

Well-known member
Joined
7 Oct 2001
Messages
1,717
Location
River Orwell,East Coast
Visit site
I can also confirm S/H support is good.My S/h 2100 screen had lines on it after about 26 months.Although it was technically out of guarantee the replaced the screen free of charge and got it back to me in 3 days.
No association just a happy customer.
 

wooslehunter

Active member
Joined
31 Oct 2002
Messages
1,959
Location
Hants, UK
Visit site
I always find the best way of picking something like this is to create a short list from recommendations & the download the user manuals.

I did this a while ago & went for Raymarine 54e. Although operation is simple & it's worked fine, build quality is poor. The sprung cover over the emergency button has broken twice. I'm on my 3rd front panel. The first one failed & stopped accepting NMEA position info for the GMDSS. The mike fell apart on the 2nd one.

Icom do make good radios & I'd probably go for one of those if I replace again. I use these on VERY wet boats & they get a hell of a beating. Generally the radios are fine but the mics fail. But, this is very extreme treatment. They'd be fine on normal boating, especially if kept under cover.
 

Alpha22

Active member
Joined
22 Sep 2003
Messages
1,413
Location
Cambridgeshire
Visit site
I did this a while ago & went for Raymarine 54e. Although operation is simple & it's worked fine, build quality is poor. The sprung cover over the emergency button has broken twice. I'm on my 3rd front panel. The first one failed & stopped accepting NMEA position info for the GMDSS. The mike fell apart on the 2nd one.

Thats interesting as I always assumed that Raymarine were a quality product at a premium price....??
 

Puggy

Member
Joined
7 May 2007
Messages
391
Location
Hampshire, UK
Visit site
+1 for Icom.

I have always bought Icom and been very happy. The Icom M323 is under £200. I have always found Icom's aftersales service to be excellent - fast, helpful and good value.

Puggy
 
Top