Boat test and some unexpected guests...

kcrane

Well-Known Member
Joined
13 Jul 2005
Messages
1,933
Location
Cheltenham
Visit site
We were out on Saturday at the invitation of the sales guys at Marine Ventures, and the kind offer of owners Pete and Hilary, to try their Prestige 46.

Weather was lovely with very little wind. For part of the day the sun shone and you could imagine spring was on its way.

Though not at Fairline quality the boat was solid and seemed robustly engineered. The space is excellent for 46ft. The layout gives you a dinette for 4 next to the helm where you can see out, a sunken galley with reasonable work surfaces, and a saloon table for 6. All 3 cabins have doubles (no bunks) and there are two heads. There is a lazarette with OK space, but also access to a smaller secondary lazarette in the saloon. The crew cabin is a fair size, big enough that Peter's had fitted a washing machine and freezer. She cruised very smoothly at 25knts. The Cummins 500hp engines were noticably quieter than others I've tried, and the controls well engineered. You can choose to "sync & link" the engines. You then control them both in unison from one lever, and the software keeps them running at equal revs.

The downside was the handling. The steering is not powered, and at higher speeds it becomes heavy, and turns are at best stately. The last boat I tried was a Targa 52, which I think is known for good handling. I expected the Prestige to feel like a regular saloon next to the Targa's sports car handling, but it felt more like van. I have a question about it that I'll post separately.

The surprise was that Peter seems to know everyone in Weymouth, including the Coastguard, and once we were out and heading for Lulworth, they were on Ch73 and asking to do a practise run.

pic01.jpg


The approach as we ran into the wind at about 25knts.

pic02.jpg


They came up from behind low over the water, and it isn't quiet, they couldn't sneak up on you!

pic03.jpg


They were just above the flybridge, close enough you felt you could reach up and touch the nose wheel. They dropped the under-carriage as they approached, not sure why.

pic04.jpg


The drop was onto the bathing platform.

pic05.jpg


Then back around, another approach, pick-up and they were off again. We didn't get a shot of their next manouver, which was to fly out half a mile in front of us, swing around how choppers do when they want to show off, and came back at us at high speed. They were probably 50ft up as they passed, but it was still hands over the ears time.

Excellent stuff, and a great experience to have had if you ever need them for real. Mark and Rob from Marine Ventures are hoping they can lay the same on for every boat test.

Pics from an iPhone, so apologies for the quality!
 
Good question!

But if they needed to take everyone off, there would be a darn good reason, so point it out to sea, leave it going, and go and find it the next day where it ran out of fuel. Wonder if the insurance covers you for an abandoned boat at 25knts?
 
In that situation, they'd take off one of the RNLI or Heli crew last, and he'd depower, or a couple of RNLI guys would take it, or tow it.

Or in the situation I was party to, I helped take the evacuated boat back with a mate from my boat onboard the other boat, with me in my boat following. Left my boat on a pontoon outside the lock and the two of us took the evacuated boat through and berthed it, then I headed home in my own boat. Inshore lifeboat was there before the helicopter, so they took control of the situation onboard before the heli arrived.

I've done the exercises a few times, as I was the only numpty out near Weymouth doing 30+ knts in mid winter when very few other boats around, even though I only have a 21'er.

Scared the crap out of me one time though. I was heading for Salcombe, and thought the conditions were too bad to get there, and headed for Weymouth for an overnight stay instead. The conditions eased up, and I opened up, and suddenly heard a horrible engine noise. Turned around to see what was happening, and they came overhead at low level from asterm, waving to me!


Heart rate didn't return to normal for quite a while.
 
Must be great to get the opportunity to practice.

And hope that you never need to do it for real.
 
It's a great experience, and does make you think you're more likely to know what to do if it ever was required on your own boat.

Not so nice when it happened for real with a boat in a group of three travelling together.
 
It was exciting I have to say, and flying a chopper is obviously easy. He was able to stay static as though attached to the boat, probably has an autopilot thing, a button marked "Stay 10ft above and 6ft to one side".

Would not like to be involved for real.

I'm not surprised he frightened you coming up behind!
 
Oh they don't have an autopilot button for that type of stuff. It's all pure skill. The reason they like you to be moving, is that it's easier to fly a heli over the boat at speed than hover.

and they really, really, don't like it if you vary speed or direction, and you can expect if an RNLI team come onboard, they don't waste time, they just dive head over the side, run to the helm, and rip the steering wheel and throttle off you if you aren't doing what you've been told.

then the heli has a 'platform' moving in a set direction at constant speed

That hasn't happened to me, but I saw it first hand, and heard the story later.

People respond in different ways to real emergency situations.
 
Yes they are!

The iPhone seemed to freeze them, I think I have a couple of photos where the bendy lines are even more obvious. I did wonder if it was an optical illusion, or whether the rotors really were bending up so much.
 
did you like the 46 ? I no whats its like we did the real thing last year on way back from lundy island pic not as good as yours but was a old 1.3 megpix phone [image]
picture1.jpg
[/image] looking forward to getting going again short vid just a run home [image]http://[/image]
 
Great stuff. Only happened to me once - fisrt trip out on new boat in 2004, they buzzed us and asked to land one of their guys on the swim platform. It all went as it did with you, quite exciting. But the helipcopter was too lound to communicate over the VHF - they had to fly away, talk to us, then come back for the manoeuvre

The iphone is doing weird things with the rotor image on the closeups

So are you sold on the p46? Nice machine. Why has he mounted the raymarine dome in such an odd position? I'm amazed to hear there is no power steering - on that sized boat you need it unless you are happy to have zillions of turns lock to lock!
 
Yep, goodness knows how the iphone did that, is there any one on the form with qualifications in optics and imagining?

We did like the P46, the more you check it out the more fundamentally sound it seems, but it just fails to have that special something that pulls you in, so I'd buy it with my head if not my heart.

If the Cummins computers were to be believed, at a reasonable cruise of I think 22knts, it seemed to be bettering 1mpg.

I'll report back on tomorrow's trial of an altogether different boat!
 
Top