Insurance for the older boat

neil_s

Well-known member
Joined
28 Oct 2002
Messages
1,523
Location
Chichester
Visit site
I have owned my Seal 28, built in 1977, for 18 years. I have been through the rigmarole of getting surveys done for the comprehensive insurance twice before - and now they want me to do it again. This time, though, they want a surveyor's valuation. Up until now, the insurance company has accepted the purchase price as the value. I have to confess that I have maintained and repaired the boat and it's gear over this time and she suits me very well, but I have not invested in any new stuff - apart from a couple of new sails. In effect, I have a time capsule from the 80's! I am well aware that this policy means my boat is probably of very little value to anyone except myself. Some thought on the matter suggests that a 3rd party insurance policy might be more appropriate. I'd appreciate any pointers towards brokers or insurance companies who might offer a service aimed at the low value boater!
 

[178529]

...
Joined
28 Apr 2020
Messages
526
Visit site
With my boat, I reckon it's worth maybe 10k, 12k tops. I've just insured her 3rd party to avoid the hassle of surveys etc etc.
 

Poignard

Well-known member
Joined
23 Jul 2005
Messages
51,352
Location
London and Brittany
Visit site
My 53 year old boat is insured through W-G Yacht Insurance.

The premium is very reasonable and there was no need for a survey; A self-certification and a couple of recent photos was all that was required

WG Yachts
 

Porthandbuoy

Well-known member
Joined
27 Apr 2003
Messages
5,309
Location
The Gareloch
www.backbearing.com
1967 Nicholson 26. Insured with Amlin (formerly RKJ) Fixed value, 3rd part, legal & personal injury (crew). Never been asked for a survey. I send them a report every year telling them what I’ve fitted, fixed or replaced.
 

Dipper

Well-known member
Joined
30 May 2001
Messages
5,061
Location
Dorset
Visit site
Both my boat and the boat next to me are insured with GJW and both have just had an insurance survey. I have an agreed value which was lucky when I lost a new mast a few years ago and the repair bill came to within £1K of that value. GJW wanted a valuation provided by the surveyor for the boat next to me so I'm not quite sure what their policy on this is. Both boats are similar age and length and probably similar value - except I have a newish mast, boom and rigging!
 

Chae_73

Active member
Joined
18 Aug 2020
Messages
375
Location
London / Suffolk
Visit site
I've taken out a policy with GJW for our recently acquired 33 year old Westerly.

It's subject to a "full out of the water survey", which I'm in the process of arranging. What should I expect to pay for this? I don't feel that I need all the inventory checks etc that you get with a buyer's survey, so would expect it to be quicker / cheaper.... obviously, I could be disappointed in that!
 

sailorman

Well-known member
Joined
21 May 2003
Messages
78,862
Location
Here or thertemp ashore
Visit site
I've taken out a policy with GJW for our recently acquired 33 year old Westerly.

It's subject to a "full out of the water survey", which I'm in the process of arranging. What should I expect to pay for this? I don't feel that I need all the inventory checks etc that you get with a buyer's survey, so would expect it to be quicker / cheaper.... obviously, I could be disappointed in that!
Why not try Quotation | Y Yacht Insurance
they may not req a survey
 

Aeolus

Active member
Joined
3 Aug 2004
Messages
991
Location
Sussex
Visit site
Thanks, will try them next time - however I've already bought the boat and paid for the policy.
An Insurance survey should cost a bit less than a purchase one but you need to beware that some inexperienced / not very good surveyors will look at stuff that is irrelevant to the insurability and will make also recommendations that are potentially very costly to address.

My last insurance survey, the surveyor wanted to inspect the bolts that secure the stem fitting. The only way to have done that in the case of my boat would have been to dismantle/destroy the entire fore-cabin. It took me a lot of time to persuade him to change his recommendation of "Remove and inspect the bolts" to a note that stated "I was unable to inspect the bolts". The problem with insurance surveys is that the brokers/companies (and it was GJW in my case) will issue a policy with a statement "subject to all recommendations having been addressed".

In your place, I would ask about who can do a good insurance survey and prioritise that over the survey cost.

(p.s. 10 years later and my stem fitting has still, happily, not detached itself from the boat)
 

Biggles Wader

Well-known member
Joined
3 Mar 2013
Messages
10,741
Location
London
Visit site
1967 Nicholson 26. Insured with Amlin (formerly RKJ) Fixed value, 3rd part, legal & personal injury (crew). Never been asked for a survey. I send them a report every year telling them what I’ve fitted, fixed or replaced.
3rd party or comp? They wont require a survey for 3rd party as they are not covering you against gear failures or you doing damage to your own boat and the boat value isnt important. They cover you for third party liabilities such as you damaging another boat and wreck removal which are requirements for most harbours and marinas.
 

neil_s

Well-known member
Joined
28 Oct 2002
Messages
1,523
Location
Chichester
Visit site
Thank you very much all - and especially Poignard for the WG yachts lead. It seems I'm not alone. I am with GJW and have been for several years, but I feel the value of my boat and it's contents does not require fully comprehensive insurance any more. I must admit that I haven't asked GJW about 3rd party yet but their site certainly seems to lean the other way! I would also like to get away from the survey requirement - I paid £318 back in 2014 for this.
 

sailorman

Well-known member
Joined
21 May 2003
Messages
78,862
Location
Here or thertemp ashore
Visit site
Thank you very much all - and especially Poignard for the WG yachts lead. It seems I'm not alone. I am with GJW and have been for several years, but I feel the value of my boat and it's contents does not require fully comprehensive insurance any more. I must admit that I haven't asked GJW about 3rd party yet but their site certainly seems to lean the other way! I would also like to get away from the survey requirement - I paid £318 back in 2014 for this.
I am with Y-Yacht Insurance on an "all risk & agreed value" policy. Unlike cars there isnt really a "Fully Comp" policy with boats, the overriding most important thing is "read the exclusions" coz that is what IS NOT covered
 

sailorman

Well-known member
Joined
21 May 2003
Messages
78,862
Location
Here or thertemp ashore
Visit site
Thank you very much all - and especially Poignard for the WG yachts lead. It seems I'm not alone. I am with GJW and have been for several years, but I feel the value of my boat and it's contents does not require fully comprehensive insurance any more. I must admit that I haven't asked GJW about 3rd party yet but their site certainly seems to lean the other way! I would also like to get away from the survey requirement - I paid £318 back in 2014 for this.
So a years premium every 5 years to indemnify the Insurance Co
 
Top