I thought the French were the safety conscious ones?!

dom

Well-known member
Joined
17 Dec 2003
Messages
7,141
Visit site
Anyone have one of these fitted? Any good? Seems like still nowhere very high up on the transom to grab and body weight will swing under the stern. Suppose it depends on the boat Osculati Flushmount Safety Ladder | Force 4 Chandlery

https://dkutenx65dka0.cloudfront.net/product-media/2S3/300/300/Force-4-Flushmount-Emergency-Ladder.jpg


Yes, it works very well, but one has to learn how to climb the damn things. Climbing sideways is easy, but quite counterintuitive!
 

Adios

...
Joined
20 Sep 2020
Messages
2,390
Visit site
Have you tried that contraption, Mr T? I wouldn't want to have to rely on it.

A stiff ladder with rungs that extend 3ft below the waterline, is just about the bare minimum for average people's usability.
It doesn't look great. I'm not with the poor logic of having something useless for when you need functionality the most.
 

dom

Well-known member
Joined
17 Dec 2003
Messages
7,141
Visit site
Don't you just swing sideways still? Do you have one and used it?


That's the danger! - one can't use the same technique as a regular ladder where one just leans back and starts to climb.

The trick is to keep the forces vertical and there are a number of ways to do this which require a bit of practice. The advantage of going up sideways is that it encourages the climber to forget traditional ladder technique and switch over to rope climbing technique, which is of course what it is. Also the ladder has to have a suitable immersion because tucking one's legs up to start is very suboptimal. Depending on transom shape a handhold or two there can be useful

A fixed ladder is of course better but doesn't suit all boats.
 

Concerto

Well-known member
Joined
16 Jul 2014
Messages
5,957
Location
Chatham Maritime Marina
Visit site
Anyone have one of these fitted? Any good? Seems like still nowhere very high up on the transom to grab and body weight will swing under the stern. Suppose it depends on the boat Osculati Flushmount Safety Ladder | Force 4 Chandlery

https://dkutenx65dka0.cloudfront.net/product-media/2S3/300/300/Force-4-Flushmount-Emergency-Ladder.jpg
That was my solution after the problem I experienced and mentioned in post #19. This allows someone to just raise themselves sufficiently out of the water to use the boarding ladder. The boarding ladder can be used for support and being rigid will also help anyone out of the water better than the red handhold. I also altered the top fixing of the ladder from on the deck to on the transom and this made the bottom step 6" lower. As they say, every little bit helps. Having done this work I hope I personally never have to use it or get someone else to try it for real.

IMG_1560 1000pix.jpgIMG_1548 1000pix.jpgIMG_1551 1000pix.jpg
 

prv

Well-known member
Joined
29 Nov 2009
Messages
37,363
Location
Southampton
Visit site
At what point (size? speed?) do people stop using kill cords? I have serious thought about fitting one for my auxiliary.

Basically anything where the size and style of boat renders it unlikely that you’ll fall directly overboard from behind the wheel. The faster the boat the further you might get thrown, so speed feeds into it too.

Pete
 

prv

Well-known member
Joined
29 Nov 2009
Messages
37,363
Location
Southampton
Visit site
Who has a ladder that enables a middle-aged low-fitness swimmer to climb aboard?

I do - and last year we tested it in anger, too, when someone fell off a pontoon in the marina.

At first I was trying to help him directly back onto the pontoon with a loop of warp to stand on, but that clearly wasn’t working. In theory the marina has emergency ladders, but they’re quite widely spaced and hard to find. It would be a long swim around a lot of boats to reach one. So he half-swam, half towed on the warp I’d looped round him, round one finger pontoon to my stern and easily came up my ladder. Should have thought of it straight away, but for the first thirty seconds or so I was focused on trying to pull him straight out at the point he’d gone in.

I lowered the ladder for him, of course, but it is reachable from the water too.

Pete
 

dancrane

Well-known member
Joined
29 Dec 2010
Messages
10,056
Visit site
I do - and last year we tested it in anger, too, when someone fell off a pontoon in the marina. In theory the marina has emergency ladders, but they’re quite widely spaced and hard to find...he half-swam and easily came up my ladder...it is reachable from the water too.

Very few boats seem to be similarly equipped - particularly with a ladder that the swimmer himself can launch without knowing in advance that he'll need it. Seems like the right ladder can turn a man-overboard incident from shatteringly arduous and highly dangerous, to just inconvenient and uncomfortable, if it:

- has a bottom rung within easy reach of the swimmer's feet;
- is launchable from the water while in its stowed position;
- is rigid in use so the positions of its rungs are predictable and reassuring; and
- can be easily used by someone who's frightened and disorientated, without requiring practice or explanation.

I only had a quickly-deployable rope ladder in a bag, and didn't fancy testing it. So, I bought an aluminium five-rung. It still needed setting up in advance, and seemed disturbingly flexible - or perhaps I've got a lot fatter - but I wouldn't trust any kind of rope or wire tangle, least of all for when the casualty may be in shock, hypothermic or panicking.
 
Last edited:

Stemar

Well-known member
Joined
12 Sep 2001
Messages
22,540
Location
Home - Southampton, Boat - Gosport
Visit site
Not that a proper stiff ladder in a locker on board, or detachable guardwires that need someone on deck, will help the inadvertent swimmer who was single-handing.
That's why I'm a bit of a fanatic about my boarding ladder on the transom being able to be folded down from in the water. I tow my flubber, so I tied a small fender across the ladder to protect the tender if it bumped us. Then I had to do something in the tender, and had a Tom & Jerry moment resulting in "Oh, I could get wet here. Oh, I am wet" No biggie, the water was warm enough, but I couldn't get the fender off to use the ladder. Had I been alone, it could have been very nasty.
 

dancrane

Well-known member
Joined
29 Dec 2010
Messages
10,056
Visit site
I suppose on a fold-down transom ladder like Concerto's, there's no good reason why the folding segment should be unhelpfully shorter than the fixed section...

...it seems to have been designed exclusively for tender-users, not swimmers. But if the folding section had as many rungs (or more) as the fixed, the same design could fold into almost the same small space, yet make it fairly easy for a swimmer to self-rescue.
 

westhinder

Well-known member
Joined
15 Feb 2003
Messages
2,471
Location
Belgium
Visit site
I lowered the ladder for him, of course, but it is reachable from the water too.

Pete

I have tied a piece of string on my swimming ladder, so it can be pulled down by someone in the water.
A couple of years ago, someone nearly drowned in our harbour in circumstances much like your description. After that the marina suggested that people should make their transom ladders deployable from the water. A good call imho
 

anoccasionalyachtsman

Well-known member
Joined
15 Jun 2015
Messages
4,173
Visit site
I suppose on a fold-down transom ladder like Concerto's, there's no good reason why the folding segment should be unhelpfully shorter than the fixed section...

...it seems to have been designed exclusively for tender-users, not swimmers. But if the folding section had as many rungs (or more) as the fixed, the same design could fold into almost the same small space, yet make it fairly easy for a swimmer to self-rescue.
I can't for the life of me remember who built them but there was a production cruiser/racer that had a ladder so long that it formed the gate for a central opening in the pushpit. It seemed so sensible and I've never understood why it wasn't widely copied.
 

Beelzebub

Well-known member
Joined
7 Jul 2008
Messages
3,620
Visit site
The X-99 had that arrangement. We used it in anger once when I went overboard in the middle of a race. I hung on to the sheet that I was handling as I went over the side. I was then able to pay out enough of the sheet to get to the stern whilst in the drink. The crew lowered the transom ladder and I was back up and racing in no time. We lost a couple of boat places but that was all.
 

peteK

Well-known member
Joined
4 May 2009
Messages
1,428
Location
Wirral
Visit site
Silly me, because of this sort of micromanagement Sailing Licences and Boat Permits - France - Angloinfo I assumed the French had a great respect for the sea and methodically preserving life, big on training courses etc

And then I see this horror show / comedy gold and now I'm confused! Amazing stuff though. And there are loads more. No life jackets of course, and what's a kill cord? "6ft breakers? great my 4hp outboard should be suitable". Favourite bit was when one of them start bailing while the skipper was still overboard. It all seems so contrary to the heavy regulation they have though.

This isn't in France its Haulover inlet in the US.Hence the lack of lifejackets.
 

dancrane

Well-known member
Joined
29 Dec 2010
Messages
10,056
Visit site
...there was a production cruiser/racer that had a ladder so long that it formed the gate for a central opening in the pushpit.

That's exactly what I was thinking, looking at Concerto's transom and pushpit.
It certainly is an obvious-seeming system that would surely save lives - like seatbelts, it shouldn't be a question of style or patent.

This isn't in France its Haulover inlet in the US. Hence the lack of lifejackets.

I hope you jest? That video made me think of Haulover, but it surely isn't the same place. If anyone enjoyed the antics seen above, and hasn't seen the numerous Haulover videos and others such as below, there is amusement awaiting you (and plenty of room to scorn our American friends)...

 
Last edited:

mjcoon

Well-known member
Joined
18 Jun 2011
Messages
4,407
Location
Berkshire, UK
www.mjcoon.plus.com
I have tied a piece of string on my swimming ladder, so it can be pulled down by someone in the water.
A couple of years ago, someone nearly drowned in our harbour in circumstances much like your description. After that the marina suggested that people should make their transom ladders deployable from the water. A good call imho
And a suggestion that would not cost the marina a single cent!
 

Adios

...
Joined
20 Sep 2020
Messages
2,390
Visit site
I hope you jest? That video made me think of Haulover, but it surely isn't the same place. If anyone enjoyed the antics seen above, and hasn't seen the numerous Haulover videos and others such as below, there is amusement awaiting you (and plenty of room to scorn our American friends)...

At least their beer cooler survived. It's size explains everything else

2021-01-18_211350.jpg
 

Beelzebub

Well-known member
Joined
7 Jul 2008
Messages
3,620
Visit site
I have tied a piece of string on my swimming ladder, so it can be pulled down by someone in the water.
A couple of years ago, someone nearly drowned in our harbour in circumstances much like your description. After that the marina suggested that people should make their transom ladders deployable from the water. A good call imho knew two people who

I knew two people who met their end by falling into the marina at night-time, with nobody else around. At the time the marina didn't have ladders from the pontoons into the water. Fortunately that changed but too late for those two guys.
 
Top