Have any of you guys considered going over to the Dark Side...

GravyStain

Active member
Joined
6 Oct 2020
Messages
273
Visit site
Yes, I'm talking about powered Catamarans.

Lots of upsides:-

Fuel efficient
Loads of space on the main deck
decent flybridges
minimal roll at anchor - no seakeeper required
less sea-sickness as per the above

Lot's of downsides:-

Not exactly good looking
Cramped cabins
Not fast
Not so luxurious
hard to get marina berths on the fly
expensive marina costs
expensive lift out / in costs

Waddaya think guys - have any of you been tempted, or indeed got one. I'm still heavily reearching my options. I can't say that I'm enthralled by an older powered cat, but some of the new ones look great (but also pricey).
 

Steruth1

Member
Joined
1 Sep 2013
Messages
194
Location
Southampton
Visit site
i have too been tempted but after being in the Med for 3 seasons it seems impossible or mega expensive to find a mooring. the boats i think have come on loads and offer great accommodation now and will certainly be cheaper on fuel, but maybe thats where the benefits end.... be good to hear from a owner who has transitioned
 

GravyStain

Active member
Joined
6 Oct 2020
Messages
273
Visit site
i have too been tempted but after being in the Med for 3 seasons it seems impossible or mega expensive to find a mooring. the boats i think have come on loads and offer great accommodation now and will certainly be cheaper on fuel, but maybe thats where the benefits end.... be good to hear from a owner who has transitioned
Yeah - that's my take on it too. The older stuff from 200(ish) just don't feel special inside. the newer ones are far more luxury yacht-like with berths to match...
 

Bluemu

New member
Joined
8 May 2019
Messages
17
Visit site
Have one :). But ours is aluminium and an expedition boat, not a gin palace.
Because we are narrow for our length, no problems with haulout or marinas (15m long, 4.9m wide).
Don’t know about slow, but I’d say most powercats are faster than their brethren if you compare SD hulls to the usual D. But speed depends on you, your wallet, needs, tank size, etc.
 

Bouba

Well-known member
Joined
6 Sep 2016
Messages
37,979
Location
SoF
Visit site
Every year the amount of cats, both power and sail, increases in the Med. A lot is due to the hire companies.
As a boat they are fabulous, they look good and have incredible amounts of room. As a neighbor they are a pain. It is hard to manœuvre around them in the close confines of a port or river, and they take up all the good mooring spots. They are only charged for one and a half places but they take two. And quite often their mooring lines take another place either side of them
 

Seastoke

Well-known member
Joined
20 Sep 2011
Messages
11,357
Visit site
Yes, I'm talking about powered Catamarans.

Lots of upsides:-

Fuel efficient
Loads of space on the main deck
decent flybridges
minimal roll at anchor - no seakeeper required
less sea-sickness as per the above

Lot's of downsides:-

Not exactly good looking
Cramped cabins
Not fast
Not so luxurious
hard to get marina berths on the fly
expensive marina costs
expensive lift out / in costs

Waddaya think guys - have any of you been tempted, or indeed got one. I'm still heavily reearching my options. I can't say that I'm enthralled by an older powered cat, but some of the new ones look great (but also pricey).
Have you seen p52 on ebay
 

Bajansailor

Well-known member
Joined
27 Dec 2004
Messages
6,452
Location
Marine Surveyor in Barbados
Visit site
Have one :). But ours is aluminium and an expedition boat, not a gin palace.

Blumu, could you post a photo or two of your power cat please?
The cat in my avatar is also 15 m. x 4.9 m and aluminium - she has 2 x 150 hp O/B motors.

@Irish Rover on this Forum has a Fountaine Pajot power cat - he has often mentioned the significant economy of proceeding underway with just one engine running.
 

skipmac

Well-known member
Joined
20 Apr 2011
Messages
2,039
Location
Winter in Florida, Summer Martha's Vineyard
Visit site
We chartered a 52 power cat from the Moorings in Nassau a couple of years ago. Have to say it was a nice holiday. Boat was fast enough, cruised at 25 kts and for the size and speed excellent mileage.

Huge amount of room. Wife, who has had a few skin cancers removed, has to keep out of the midday sun which was not only easy to do but also open to the view with lots of big windows, unlike being below in our sailboat.

Wouldn't want to take it out in nasty weather.
 

Irish Rover

Well-known member
Joined
5 Feb 2017
Messages
5,330
Location
Türkiye
Visit site
Blumu, could you post a photo or two of your power cat please?
The cat in my avatar is also 15 m. x 4.9 m and aluminium - she has 2 x 150 hp O/B motors.

@Irish Rover on this Forum has a Fountaine Pajot power cat - he has often mentioned the significant economy of proceeding underway with just one engine running.
We really like this boat. It's 10.3 x 4.45M so it affords us a huge amount of space compared to a similar length monohull. An island berth would be nice but you can't have everything. 95% of motoring on one engine doing 7 Kn and burning 3.5LPH.
Now that I realise just how manoeuvrable it is we'd like to upgrade to a somewhat bigger cat. The two things we miss most are a generator and a deep freeze. I know I could retrofit on our Greenland 34 but it wouldn't be easy or ideal. We're on the lookout for a Leopard 39 or 43 or perhaps a FP Summerland 40. Might need to wait a bit though as our business has been affected by covid.
 

GravyStain

Active member
Joined
6 Oct 2020
Messages
273
Visit site
We really like this boat. It's 10.3 x 4.45M so it affords us a huge amount of space compared to a similar length monohull. An island berth would be nice but you can't have everything. 95% of motoring on one engine doing 7 Kn and burning 3.5LPH.
Now that I realise just how manoeuvrable it is we'd like to upgrade to a somewhat bigger cat. The two things we miss most are a generator and a deep freeze. I know I could retrofit on our Greenland 34 but it wouldn't be easy or ideal. We're on the lookout for a Leopard 39 or 43 or perhaps a FP Summerland 40. Might need to wait a bit though as our business has been affected by covid.
That's amazingly frugal at 7 kts.
 

Seastoke

Well-known member
Joined
20 Sep 2011
Messages
11,357
Visit site
That vintage has a huge space to step onto the bathing platform from the side.
Just look at the photo.
Not much help if it is on a Med style berth but if berthed on a pontoon, it must be one of the easiest boats to get on and off.
Great vintage though.
Is it a good price.
 

Bluemu

New member
Joined
8 May 2019
Messages
17
Visit site
Blumu, could you post a photo or two of your power cat please?
The cat in my avatar is also 15 m. x 4.9 m and aluminium - she has 2 x 150 hp O/B motors.

@Irish Rover on this Forum has a Fountaine Pajot power cat - he has often mentioned the significant economy of proceeding underway with just one engine running.
We were looking at the Greenland 34, then found ours - Bluenomads.blog is our pretty quiet blog and has pictures.
I have also done a little study of the fuel consumption of many of the blue-water capable powercats which is on the blog too.

img_0487.jpg


Just so you know, we aren’t just on the Dark Side, we are planning on the full blackened monty: we are planning going parallel hybrid electric with a 8+ kW solar array.
 
Last edited:

Alicatt

Well-known member
Joined
6 Nov 2017
Messages
4,414
Location
Eating in Eksel or Ice Cold in Alex
Visit site
For a dive boat we looked at a cat, it was a fishing boat, plenty of room, nice and steady, powerful diesel engines one in each side, but watching between the hulls as we approached hull speed the bow wash was hitting the underside of the central span and causing a lot of buffeting , she got to hull speed at less than 1/2 throttle and would not go any faster.
Going through the boat's documents, the builder had taken the plans from a normal mono hull boat, split it down the middle and made a cat out of it, interesting idea and a stable boat but a disaster all at the same time.

No we didn't buy it, after the sea trial we said thanks but no thanks.
 
Top