Crossing Vessels

fisherman

Well-known member
Joined
2 Dec 2005
Messages
19,575
Location
Far S. Cornwall
Visit site
yes to the one nm range, it's what i relied on when beset by ships, I became very attentive if a ship got inside a mile.
The advantage of you turning to port is it immediately makes him give way as overtaking vessel, and reduces the closing speed. As you carry on turning he remains give way and it gives you more options if he misbehaves. A complete 360 of sufficiently large radius places you astern and safe.
If you were in a ship rather than a boat you would have to.
 

mainsail1

Well-known member
Joined
27 May 2008
Messages
2,369
Location
Returned to South Coast from West Coast of Scotlan
Visit site
Presumably thought if CPA >1 mile then noone needs make a course change ?
We are talking about collision or near miss avoidance here. If your CPA remains at more than 1/4 of a mile (or about 3 cables) I would not expect action to be taken by a small boat in good visibility although it would be helpful for you to alter to pass a bit further away.
 
Last edited:

Yealm

Well-known member
Joined
13 Apr 2017
Messages
5,337
Visit site
So would this an accurate summing up (eg if crossing TSS) ?

1) A long way apart - either vessel can change course to keep CPA >1nm
2) Getting closer - Colregs applies so only one vessel should be changing course if necessary
3) Very close - Colregs collision rules now apply !

And the distance that defines the change from (1) to (2) is mysterious and undefined :)
 

GHA

Well-known member
Joined
26 Jun 2013
Messages
12,104
Location
Hopefully somewhere warm
Visit site
I love AIS. Actually observing a professional change course to give me a CPA>1 nm when I'm the stand-on vessel. Very comforting.
And I can do the same for him when I'm giving way.
?
Seem in the channel quite a few times, ship many miles away will tweak its' course to give almost exactly 1nm cpa. Really good idea to stand on as the ship will be doing the same for many vessels you don't even know exist..

Way offshore often they do course changes before they appear over the horizon.

Having a good radar return is a really good idea, even with ais transmitting.
 

GHA

Well-known member
Joined
26 Jun 2013
Messages
12,104
Location
Hopefully somewhere warm
Visit site
So would this an accurate summing up (eg if crossing TSS) ?

1) A long way apart - either vessel can change course to keep CPA >1nm
2) Getting closer - Colregs applies so only one vessel should be changing course if necessary
3) Very close - Colregs collision rules now apply !

And the distance that defines the change from (1) to (2) is mysterious and undefined :)

Rule 8 >
Rule 8
The action taken should allow sufficient sea room for the safe passage of the other vessel. You are required not to impede the passage or safe passage of another vessel
(f)

(i) A vessel which, by any of these Rules, is required not to impede the passage or safe passage of another vessel shall, when required by the circumstances of the case, take early action to allow sufficient sea room for the safe passage of the other vessel.
?

Everything you need is in the irpcs, read and comply :) And they say don't comply if it's a stupid thing to do ;)


Just came across some more youtube....

 

mainsail1

Well-known member
Joined
27 May 2008
Messages
2,369
Location
Returned to South Coast from West Coast of Scotlan
Visit site
So would this an accurate summing up (eg if crossing TSS) ?

1) A long way apart - either vessel can change course to keep CPA >1nm
2) Getting closer - Colregs applies so only one vessel should be changing course if necessary
3) Very close - Colregs collision rules now apply !

And the distance that defines the change from (1) to (2) is mysterious and undefined :)

So would this an accurate summing up (eg if crossing TSS) ?

1) A long way apart - either vessel can change course to keep CPA >1nm
2) Getting closer - Colregs applies so only one vessel should be changing course if necessary
3) Very close - Colregs collision rules now apply !

And the distance that defines the change from (1) to (2) is mysterious and undefined :)

This is too simplistic. Seamanship is learned with experience. No two cases are the same because there are variable factors such as the weather, size of vessels, speed of vessels, types of vessels etc. If you stick to the basic rule that if you are give way vessel and there is a risk of collision you need to give way in good time with a bold alteration of course (so that there are no misunderstandings). To begin with, any vessel with a CPA of less than 1 mile is a risk but you can refine that as you gain more experience.
 

johnalison

Well-known member
Joined
14 Feb 2007
Messages
38,730
Location
Essex
Visit site
In my experience, a single ship seldom gives cause for concern, but it is when there are two vessels, maybe from different directions and at different speeds, that difficulties arise. This is possibly where AIS comes in most useful, but, as m1 says, facility only comes with experience.
 

GHA

Well-known member
Joined
26 Jun 2013
Messages
12,104
Location
Hopefully somewhere warm
Visit site
If you stick to the basic rule that if you are give way vessel and there is a risk of collision you need to give way in good time with a bold alteration of course
?
You sound like you may have spent some time on the bridge of big ships - if so what distance would you start getting a bit concerned in open water/shipping lanes if a risk of collision existed and the a give way yacht did nothing? Usually think I'd be doing something obvious at about 2 or 3 Nm off, even if it was a big course change for a couple minutes then back a little just to hopefully make it clear that to the ship that it's been seen and shouldn't need to do anything.
 

mainsail1

Well-known member
Joined
27 May 2008
Messages
2,369
Location
Returned to South Coast from West Coast of Scotlan
Visit site
?
You sound like you may have spent some time on the bridge of big ships - if so what distance would you start getting a bit concerned in open water/shipping lanes if a risk of collision existed and the a give way yacht did nothing? Usually think I'd be doing something obvious at about 2 or 3 Nm off, even if it was a big course change for a couple minutes then back a little just to hopefully make it clear that to the ship that it's been seen and shouldn't need to do anything.

Would start thinking of action at 1mile but does depend on closing speed and all kinds of other factors.
 

johnalison

Well-known member
Joined
14 Feb 2007
Messages
38,730
Location
Essex
Visit site
Although I might be happy to pass a few cables astern of a ship, I would be less happy if it were fast-moving and its wake likely to be a problem. On the other hand, I might have a mental image of leaving a mile clearance, but in practice seeing a ship pass half a mile or less ahead or astern does happen occasionally and I don't remember being concerned about it.
 

TernVI

Well-known member
Joined
8 Jul 2020
Messages
5,070
Visit site
The problem is often that a yacht's course and speed varies and the calculated CPA may change a lot.
A smaller CPA is acceptable if you are clearly going to go behind the ship.
Committing to passing more than 2 miles in front of something can get nervy when the wind drops or shifts.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RAI

TernVI

Well-known member
Joined
8 Jul 2020
Messages
5,070
Visit site
Although I might be happy to pass a few cables astern of a ship, I would be less happy if it were fast-moving and its wake likely to be a problem. On the other hand, I might have a mental image of leaving a mile clearance, but in practice seeing a ship pass half a mile or less ahead or astern does happen occasionally and I don't remember being concerned about it.
A ship which passes half a mile dead astern of a slow yacht is not as much of a risk as yacht being a mile dead ahead of the ship.
You can be 50ft from a ship alongside it and there's no way it can hit you. If you are passing in front of it and lose power, how much time does the ship have to react?
Margin for error is not equal in all directions as the yacht can alter course or speed very quickly, the only thing it cannot do is outpace the ship.
I can't immediately express this clearly but CPA is not a very good measure of the margin for error between a slow yacht which can turn in its own length and a faster ship with a limited rate of turn and acceleration/deceleration.

Also when your AIS computer calculates the CPA, there is a lot of uncertainty to be added into the yacht's course and rather less in the course of the ship.
The big advantage of AIS is seeing the ship's COG change before it's visually obvious.

I might be thinking there's a risk of collision, while he knows he's turning into LeHavre.....
 

Buck Turgidson

Well-known member
Joined
10 Apr 2012
Messages
3,125
Location
Zürich
Visit site
When you have this:
IMG_0267.JPG

followed by this:
IMG_0268.JPG

for the good part of 6 hours. 1nm CPA would have you never crossing. This was off the Portuguese coast south of Lisbon outside the TSS.

sorry about the quality of this one, it's a video screen grab but you get the picture! Screenshot 2020-11-22 at 19.43.59.png
 
Last edited:
Top